Engaging Ideas - 3/3/2017

Every week we curate stories and reports on complex issues. This week: Do young people trust the media? How do we get evidence to show up more at school board and PTA meetings? A new report based on 200 interviews with college transfer students. And a survey that asks about the ACA in the context of lower quality care.


New report finds that American youth express low trust in media, use diverse strategies to verify news content (Knight Foundation)
Data & Society released “How Youth Navigate the News Landscape,” supported by the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation this week. The report reveals that teens and young adults express low levels of trust in the news media and use mobile and social media to confirm, verify, and clarify the stories they care about.

The Media And The Public Disagree On Definition Of Democracy (Vocativ)
Mainstream media faced criticism from all sides of the political divide for their coverage of the election campaign. President Donald Trump’s surprising victory led to accusations that journalists on the coasts are out of touch with the rest of the country and that the media is biased or elitist.


What is gender budgeting? (The Economist)
Dozens of countries have passed equal-opportunity laws and adopted UN resolutions on women’s empowerment. Some governments are now turning to gender budgeting. What is it and how does it help?

Robots won't just take our jobs – they'll make the rich even richer (The Guardian)
Should robots pay taxes? It may sound strange, but a number of prominent people have been asking this question lately. As fears about the impact of automation grow, calls for a “robot tax” are gaining momentum.

K-12 Education

Kansas Supreme Court: State Level of School Funding is Inadequate (Education Week)
The ruling supported this conclusion by citing the nearly 50 percent of African-American students in Kansas who are not proficient in reading or math, and the one-third of students who receive free or reduced-price meals who are also not proficient in these subjects.

Knocking Down Barriers to Learning for Poor Students (Education Week)
In the Greenville County, S.C., district, Superintendent W. Burke Royster enlists a wide array of partners to help keep all students engaged in school and on track to graduate. He is recognized as a 2017 Leader To Learn From.

Three Features We Hope to See in Future Education Research (Education Next)
Michael Barber and Nathan Martin write: More evidence will not change outcomes without a strong focus on how to effectively spread and scale these new ideas and practice. We should learn from the work of the Gates Foundation, which utilizes teacher networks and influencers to help the importance of evidence “go viral.” We’ll know that a transformation is truly underway when efficacy and evidence start showing up on the agenda at school board and PTA meetings.

Three ways technology can supercharge teacher training (The Hechinger Report)
Trending methods include ideas like instructional coaching, learning walks, and professional learning communities. But these methods, when implemented without technology, are mostly in-person. The impact of the efforts will always be limited by needing the right people in the right place at the right time to witness the teaching.

Higher Education & Workforce Development

Report: What We Know About Technology-Mediated Advising Reform (CCRC)
Increasingly, colleges are attempting to use the technologies as a catalyst to fundamentally redesign their advising and support services.

Report: Increasing Success for Two-to-Four-Year Transfer Students Within CUNY (Columbia University)
The yearlong collaboration between GNYC, CUNY’s Office of Policy Research, and researchers at Columbia University was motivated by the shared goal of generating a more detailed, on-the-ground understanding of the first-year trajectories of two-to-four-year transfer students within the CUNY system, especially as compared to first-time freshmen and “native” upperclassmen. To provide such an understanding, two Columbia University researchers conducted over 200 interviews between September 2015 and June 2016 from a focal sample of ten first-time freshmen and ten two-to-four-year transfer students at three CUNY four-year colleges—a total of thirty freshmen and thirty transfer students overall.

State-by-State Breakdown of Graduation Rates (The Chronicle of Higher Education)
Nationally, 16.0 percent of two-year starters received a degree from a four-year institution within six years, with or without a prior associate’s degree. In 16 states, this percentage was higher than the national average. In four states (Iowa, Kansas, North Dakota, and Virginia), one in five students who started at a two-year public institution had a four-year degree within six years. Download the full report from the National Student Clearing House here.

Cross-sector Collaboration: What the Tipping Point Looks Like (Stanford Social Innovation Review)
Five successful change management strategies from an initiative to transform higher education from Van Ton-Quinlivan, the vice chancellor of the Workforce and Economic Development Division for the California Community Colleges.

Health Care

Health Care Survey - February 22-23, 2017 (Cato Institute)
Most polling of the Affordable Care Act finds popular support for many of its benefits when no costs are mentioned. However, a new Cato Institute/YouGov survey finds that support drops, even among Democrats, if its popular provisions harm the quality of health care. The poll finds that risks of higher premiums, higher taxes, or subsidies to insurers are less concerning to Americans than harm to the quality of care.

The Risk of Expanding the Uninsured Population by Repealing the Affordable Care Act (JAMA)
Switzerland, Singapore, and Germany have achieved universal coverage and made insurance affordable even for their citizens with highest health care costs by instituting an individual mandate. One major difference, however, is that unlike the ACA, the mandates instituted by these countries are reinforced with effective penalties for nonparticipation, thus ensuring that lower-cost enrollees—generally healthier individuals—balance out the costs of the others who require more medical resources.

Data Note: Americans’ Challenges with Health Care Costs (Kaiser Health News)
Four in ten (43 percent) adults with health insurance say they have difficulty affording their deductible, and roughly a third say they have trouble affording their premiums and other cost sharing; all shares have increased since 2015.... A majority of Americans, regardless of party identification, think lowering the amount individuals pay for health care should be a “top priority” for President Trump and Congress and rank it at the top of the list of health care priorities.


Comment on this article.

Recent Blogs


Public Agenda knows what it takes to fuel progress on critical issues.
We need your support to keep things moving!

Join the Community


Take Action