Public Agenda
On The Agenda The Public Agenda Blog

Engaging Your Community: Framing for Deliberation

by Allison Rizzolo

Wednesday, October 26th, 2011

Is Social Security a failed system in need of replacement or a successful one in need of normal maintenance? Is the public school system the best hope for democracy or a state monopoly immune to reform?

The presentation of information, facts and arguments is not neutral. Different presentations, depending on language and word choice, can have very different impacts and can evoke very different connotations and reactions from our listeners. This presentation provides a context, or a frame, through which people make a value judgments.

How does framing matter in the context of engaging one's community? When working toward authentic engagement, it is important to frame an issue for deliberation, as opposed to persuasion. Framing for deliberation is another core principle for authentic engagement.


Frame issues for deliberation

Framing for deliberation involves clarifying the range of positions surrounding an issue so that citizens can better decide what they want to do. Your charge in engaging your community is not to get your audience to do what you want to do, and it is important you consciously avoid framing to persuade an audience by defining an issue to your advantage.

Framing for deliberation can happen naturally, but in order to encourage this, it is important, again, to speak the language and address the concerns of your community members. Framing an issue for public deliberation requires focusing more on values-related conflicts and broad strategies than on technical details and tactical minutiae, which are more the province of experts. It means, in essence, helping people wrestle with different perspectives and the pros and cons of going down different paths.

Framing for deliberation communicates that there are no easy answers and that many points of view are welcome and essential to the discussion. This technique (which Public Agenda calls "Citizen Choicework") also helps people with very different levels of expertise engage both the issues and one another more effectively than a wide-open discussion with no structure.

Read more about framing or earlier principles of public engagement. If you have any questions, just ask on our Facebook page or via Twitter.

We also have many more tools to help foster community and public engagement. These include Choicework discussion guides, deliberative discussion starters for flexible use among diverse participants, and their corresponding videos; reports outlining engagement recommendations and principles; and case studies in community and state engagement.



Comment on this article.

Subject:
Your Name (Optional):

Your Comment:



Help us prevent bot attacks.
Please enter the characters displayed above (case-sensitive).


Press to submit.